Schizoid personality disorder (SPD) is a personality disorder characterized by a lack of interest in
social relationships, a tendency towards a solitary lifestyle, secretiveness,
emotional coldness, and apathy. Affected
individuals may simultaneously demonstrate a rich, elaborate and exclusively
internal fantasy world.
SPD is
not the same as schizophrenia,
although they share such similar characteristics as detachment and blunted
affect. There is, moreover, increased prevalence of the disorder in
families with schizophrenia.
Some
psychologists argue that the definition of SPD is flawed due to cultural bias:
"One reason schizoid people are pathologized is because they are comparatively
rare. People in majorities tend to assume that their own psychology is normative and to equate difference with
inferiority". Therefore "[t]he so-called schizoid personality
disorder is one of the more blatant examples of the APA’s pathologizing of normal human
differences."
History
The term "schizoid" was coined in 1908 by Eugen Bleuler to
designate a human tendency to direct attention toward one's inner life and away
from the external world, a concept akin tointroversion in
that it was not viewed in terms of psychopathology. Bleuler labeled the exaggeration of
this tendency the “schizoid personality.”
Studies on the schizoid personality have developed along two
distinct paths. The "descriptive psychiatry" tradition focuses
on overtly observable, behavioral and describable symptoms and finds its
clearest exposition in the DSM-IV
revised. The dynamic psychiatry tradition includes
the exploration of covert or unconscious motivations and character structure as elaborated by
classic psychoanalysis and object-relations theory.
The descriptive tradition began in Ernst
Kretschmer's 1925 description of observable schizoid
behaviors, which he organized into three groups of characteristics:
1.
unsociability, quietness, reservedness,
seriousness, eccentricity
2.
timidity,
shyness with feelings, sensitivity, nervousness, excitability
3.
pliability,
honesty, indifference, silence, cold emotional attitudes.
These characteristics were the precursors of the DSM-IV
division of schizoid character into three distinct personality disorders,
though Kretschmer himself did not conceive of separating these behaviors to the
point of radical isolation but considered them to be simultaneously present as
varying potentials in schizoid individuals. For Kretschmer, the majority of
schizoids are not either oversensitive or cold,
but they are oversensitive and cold "at the same time" in quite
different relative proportions, with a tendency to move along these dimensions
from one behavior to the other.
The second path, that of dynamic psychiatry, began in 1924
with observations by Eugen Bleuler, who observed that the
schizoid person and schizoid pathology were
not things to be set apart. W. R. D.
Fairbairn's seminal work on the schizoid personality,
from which most of what is known today about schizoid phenomena is derived, was
presented in 1940. Here Fairbairn delineated four central schizoid themes: (1)
the need to regulate interpersonal distance as
a central focus of concern, (2) the ability to mobilize self
preservative defenses and self-reliance, (3) a pervasive
tension between the anxiety-laden need for attachment and the defensive need
for distance that manifests in observable behavior asindifference, and
(4) an overvaluation of the inner world at the expense of the outer world. Following
Fairbairn, the dynamic psychiatry tradition has continued to produce rich
explorations on the schizoid character, most notably from writers Nannarello
(1953), Laing (1960), Winnicott (1965), Guntrip (1969), Khan (1974), Akhtar (1987),
Seinfeld (1991), Manfield (1992) and Klein (1995).
Psychologist Nancy McWilliams argues that the definition of
SPD is flawed due to cultural bias: "One reason schizoid people
are pathologized is because they are
comparatively rare. People in majorities tend to assume that their own
psychology is normative and to equate difference with
inferiority." Commentators have responded McWilliams is asking for an
impossibility (norms as void as itself normative) and the more philosophically
minded psychologists have pointed out, humans functioning well in the absence
of norms realistically cannot exist and her argument represents a form of
fallacious nihilism.
In other words, the counter-argument is human beings have something like a
teleological essence, and at least some underpinning of culturally transmitted
ethics harmonious with the human telos (in Aristotelian
terms), being a necessity inescapable for human beings striving after living
well or Maslovian "flourishing", rejecting the predicted social anomie of
the unspoken relativistic or nihilistic philosophical assumptions arguably
underlying the views of McWilliams.
Largely unknown in contemporary psychological science, what
modern psychologists understand as "schizoid" has, diagnostically, a
"genealogical" and terminological antecedent in "schizothymia",
an older term once erroneously dismissed but now increasingly reassessed in
critical psycho-diagnostic research as of probable utility in managing
resistant, exceedingly complex schizoid-like conditions or schizoid
subcategories.
Sign And Symptoms
People with SPD are often aloof,
cold and indifferent, which causes interpersonal difficulty. Most individuals
diagnosed with SPD have trouble establishing personal relationships or
expressing their feelings in a meaningful way. They may remain passive in
the face of unfavorable situations. Their communication with other people may
be indifferent and concise at times. Because of their lack of meaningful
communication with other people, those who are diagnosed with SPD are not able
to develop accurate images of how well they get along with others.
Such images are believed to be important for a person's self-awareness
and ability to assess the impact of their own actions in social situations.
R.D. Laing suggests that when one is not enriched by injections of
interpersonal reality, the self-image becomes increasingly empty and volatilized,
which leads the individual to feel unreal.
When the individual's personal space is violated, they feel
suffocated and feel the need to free themselves and be independent. People who
have SPD tend to be happiest when they are in a relationship in which the
partner places few emotional or intimate demands on them. It is not
people as such that they want to avoid, but emotions both negative and
positive,emotional intimacy, and self
disclosure.
This means that it is possible for schizoid individuals to
form relationships with others based on intellectual, physical, familial,
occupational, or recreational activities as long as these modes of relating do
not require or force the need for emotional intimacy, which the affected
individual will reject. Donald
Winnicott explains this need to modulate emotional interaction
by saying that schizoid individuals "prefer to make relationships on their
own terms and not in terms of the impulses of other people." Failing to
attain that, they prefer isolation.
The ‘Secret Schizoid’
Many fundamentally schizoid
individuals present with an engaging, interactive personality style that
contradicts the observable characteristic emphasized by the DSM-IV and ICD-10
definitions of the schizoid personality. Klein classifies these
individuals as "secret schizoids", who present themselves
as socially available, interested, engaged and involved in interacting yet
remain emotionally withdrawn and sequestered within
the safety of the internal world.
Withdrawal or detachment from
the outer world is a characteristic feature of schizoid (alleged) pathology,
but may appear either in "classic" or in "secret" form.
When classic, it matches the typical description of the schizoid personality
offered in the DSM-IV. It is however "just as often" a hidden
internal state: that which meets the objective eye may not match the
subjective, internal world of the patient. Klein therefore cautions that one should
not miss identifying the schizoid patient because one cannot see the patient's
withdrawal through the patient's defensive, compensatory interaction
with external reality. He suggests that one need only ask the patient what his
or her subjective experience is in order to detect the presence of the schizoid
refusal of emotional intimacy.
Descriptions of the schizoid personality as
"hidden" behind an outward appearance of emotional engagement have
been recognized as far back as 1940 with Fairbairn's description of
"schizoid exhibitionism," in which the schizoid individual is able to
express a great deal of feeling and to make what appear to be impressive social
contacts yet in reality gives nothing and loses nothing. Because he is only
"playing a part," his own personality is not involved. According to
Fairbairn, "the person disowns the part which he is playing and
thus the schizoid individual seeks to preserve his own personality intact and
immune from compromise."
Further references to the secret schizoid come from Masud Khan,
Jeffrey Seinfeld and Philip Manfield, who gives a palpable description
of an SPD individual who actually "enjoys" regular public speaking
engagements but experiences great difficulty in the breaks when audience
members would attempt to engage him emotionally. These references expose the
problems involved in relying singularly on outer observable behavior for
assessing the presence of personality disorders in certain individuals.
Schizoid sexuality
People with SPD are sometimes sexually apathetic, though
they do not typically suffer from anorgasmia.
Many schizoids have a healthy sex drive but some prefer to masturbate rather
than deal with the social aspects of finding a sexual partner. Their preference
to remain alone and detached may cause their need for sex to appear to be less
than that of those who do not have SPD. Sex often causes individuals with SPD
to feel that their personal space is being violated, and they commonly feel
that masturbation or sexual
abstinence is preferable to the emotional closeness they must
tolerate when having sex. Significantly broadening this picture are
notable exceptions of SPD individuals who engage in occasional or even frequent
sexual activities with others.
Harry Guntrip describes the "secret sexual
affair" entered into by some married schizoid individuals as an attempt to
reduce the quantity of emotional intimacy focused within a single relationship,
a sentiment echoed by Karen Horney's "resigned personality"
who may exclude sex as "too intimate for a permanent relationship, and
instead satisfy his sexual needs with a stranger. Conversely he may more or
less restrict a relationship to merely sexual contacts and not share other
experiences with the partner." Jeffrey Seinfeld, professor of social work
at New York University, has published a volume on SPD that details
examples of "schizoid hunger" which may manifest as sexual
promiscuity. Seinfeld provides an example of a schizoid woman who would
covertly attend various bars to meet men for the purposes of gaining impersonal
sexual gratification, an act which alleviated her feelings of hunger and
emptiness.
Salman Akhtar describes this dynamic interplay of overt
versus covert sexuality and motivations of some SPD individuals with greater
accuracy. Rather than following the narrow proposition that schizoid
individuals are either sexual or asexual,
Akhtar suggests that these forces may both be present in an
individual despite their rather contradictory aims. A clinically accurate
picture of schizoid sexuality must therefore include the overt signs:
"asexual, sometimes celibate; free of romantic interests; averse to sexual gossip
andinnuendo,"
as well as possible covert manifestations of "secret
voyeuristic and pornographic interests; vulnerable to erotomania;
tendency towards compulsive masturbation andperversions," although
none of these necessarily apply to all people with SPD.
(12410079)
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar